We have an interesting decision out of a California appellate court regarding the intersection of inspection rights and forum selection clauses.
California grants shareholders an unwaivable inspection right for any company with its principal office in California, even if the company is organized elsewhere.
An 11% shareholder of privately-held Orchid – organized in Delaware, headquartered in California – sought to exercise his California inspection right. Orchid refused, claiming it would only recognize a Delaware inspection right, and the request was invalid under Delaware law. The shareholder sued in California. At which point, Orchid did two things.
First, it filed a declaratory judgment action in Delaware seeking an order that it was not obligated to comply with the California statute; and second, it moved to stay in California, claiming the applicability of its forum selection bylaw – which required any “internal affairs” claim to be litigated in Delaware.
The California trial court granted the stay, but Delaware dismissed the Orchid action, on the ground that it did not have personal jurisdiction over the shareholder.
So, the whole thing gets to the California appellate court. And the first question is, are California inspection rights “internal affairs” such that the forum selection
